A
Anonymous11/15/26, 15:21No.25655605
Is this just a big practical joke?

11
Replies
A
Anon11/15/26, 15:47No.25655633
FINALLY, somebody gets it. about damn time.
A
Anon11/15/26, 16:49No.25655727
Not a joke, but the very first sentence is a classic case of begging the question: Die Welt ist alles was der Fall ist. Then he goes on a massive tangent, rewrititing Fregel's logic in his own words and at the end he just repeats the very first sentence in other words and make it seem like he is removing the ladder.
A
Anon11/15/26, 18:11No.25655843
Wittgenstein thought that philosophy was nonsensical, yes. But good luck understanding what he wanted to mean by this.Here are the two dominant interpretations of the book. (Historically there have been three, but the first interpretation - the Vienna circle’s - is unanimously thought incorrect.)Traditional/ineffablist reading:
The propositions of the Tractatus are attempts to say what, strictly speaking, cannot be said: truths about the finalmost (logical) structure of reality. But these propositions are expertly constructed, they each fail in their own intended ways, and in that very failure “gesture” to those ineffable truths; and this is the best we can do.New/resolute reading: the propositions of the tractatus are merely or sheerly nonsensical, i.e. gibberish. The point of reading the book is to understand that there are no ultimate propositions, to rid ourselves of the temptation, including the tenacious, finalmost form of that temptation: that there might nonetheless be propositions which, in their nonsensicality, gesture toward the ineffable. Believing this is “chickening out”, as Cora Diamond, it’s main proponent, has it.That’s the lay of the interpretative land. The degree to which you think this is all a ‘practical joke’ will be proportional to the degree to which you are inclined to philosophise
A
Anon11/15/26, 18:14No.25655845
>oh no a book that needs me to understand real logic and not podcaster/ben sha-bee-bee logic!
skill issue
A
Anon11/15/26, 18:58No.25655897
SubaHibi