A
Anonymous11/01/26, 01:54No.25625843/phil/ - Philosophy General #16
>What is /phil/ Philosophy General?
A general for readers, students, and armchair thinkers interested in philosophy, whether it be Western, Eastern, analytic, continental, ancient, contemporary. We discuss primary texts, secondary literature, online lectures, podcasts.
>Why read philosophy?
Politics, science, psychology, etc. all began with or were inspired by someone who thought philosophically. Basically, if you are interested in just about anything, philosophy will help you better understand that subject. Because it is at the foundation of every conceptual institution made or discovered by humans, it is in the underbelly of human experience, and so it is worth taking seriously.
>Why study philosophy formally?
Surprisingly versatile and undervalued. Phil majors consistently score among the highest on the LSAT, GRE, and GMAT. Strong pipeline into law, policy, ethics consulting, AI alignment, and academia.
The server: https://discord.gg/uPvkn8Tcf6
/phil/ guide: https://www.scribd.com/document/324425214/Lit-Philosophy-Project-1-2

251
Replies
A
Anon11/01/26, 01:57No.25625848
There’s a “physicalist general” happening in /his/ rn, tho as with the usual nature of the board it’s about one physicalist schizo seething at any philosophical concept that isn’t completely physically halal
A
Anon11/01/26, 14:23No.25626558
Not quite philosophy but psychoanalysis. Still I think anons will get a kick out of it.
>The castration complex is the deepest unconscious root of anti-semitism; for even in the nursery little boys hear that a Jew has something cut off his penis - a piece of his penis, they think - and this gives them a right to despise Jews. And there is no stronger unconscious root for the sense of superiority over women. Weininger (the young philosopher who, highly gifted but sexually deranged, committed suicide after producing his remarkable book, Geschlecht und Charakter), in a chapter that attracted much attention, treated Jews and women with equal hostility and overwhelmed them with the same insults. Being a neurotic, Weigninger was completely under the sway of his infantile complexes; and from that standpoint what is common to Jews and women is their relation to the castration complex. - Freud, A Phobia in a 5-Year-Old Boy
Snip snip. I like this passage because Freud can respect the talent and genius the oddball genius Weininger while recognizing that his weird hangups re: Jews and women come from the failure to grow into full maturity. The castration complex is our coming up against the hostile realities of failure, people not liking us, our desires being unrealizable or not themselves desirable, etc.Where's the philosophical connection? I'm a transcendental idealist and transcendental idealism is all about the insuperable conflict between the is and the ought. Freud's castration complex is simply this conflict expressed in psychoanalytic terms. Antisemitism and misogyny (and racism for that matter) represent the right-handed dogmatism, the dogmatism that denies sensibility, or that ignores being in favor of pure thinking. It can't stand that things aren't exactly as it thinks they ought to be and turns into hatred. Obv. I'm playing fast and loose with idealistic terminology here but Fichte said we should never have any fixed terminology and I'm not actually as unmoored from the primaries as it might sound.
>The conditions of sensuous intuition, which contain in themselves their own means of distinction, [Leibniz] did not look upon as primitive, because sensibility was to him but a confused mode of representation and not any particular source of representations.
Hence noogeny, as opposed to Locke's noogony. But this is false and unbalanced, it falls to critique.
A
Anon11/01/26, 17:01No.25626828
are there any good left takes on current ai
specifically excluding any denialist crank stuff
A
Anon11/02/26, 04:57No.25628371
knowsoda.com/philosophy for a fun philosophy type quiz. apparently my guy is some guy ive never heard of but he seems cool

A
Anon11/02/26, 15:06No.25628992
>The general idea is always an abstraction and, for that very reason, in some sort a negation of real life. Human thought… can grasp and name only the general significance of real facts, but never their material, individual side, palpitating, so to speak, with reality and life, and therefore fugitive and intangible. Science comprehends the thought of the reality, not reality itself; the thought of life, not life. This is its limit, its only really insuperable limit, because it is founded on the very nature of thought, which is the only organ of science. - Bakunin, God and the State
Here the revolutionary anarchist and idealist philosopher accurately summarizes Aristotelian nominalism and anti-realism. I absolutely love this guy.

A
Anon11/02/26, 19:00No.25629450
>Philosophy General #16

A
Anon11/03/26, 16:08No.25631312
I’ve finished my first Jung, “The Psychology of the Unconscious”. In comparing him to Freud I would say first of all that there is no right or wrong in this sort of hermeneutic psychology, we’re in the realm of aesthetic interpretation, with the psyche as the art-piece being interpreted. There is simply no way to settle who is “right” about the unconscious for example. Jung illustrates this quite well when he interprets a dream now by Freud, now by Adler, and then claims that both are correct in different ways. Rather than look to the different conclusions of Freud and Jung it’s more illustrative imo to look at their methodology. Jung is a theorist seeking symmetry, he always steps back from the immediately given psychological phenomenon to seek the “sonething else” that makes it a whole. Freud is just the reverse, he has his big Jewish nose ground down in the symptoms. He is devoted to the method of free association; this means theory is always secondary to clinical experience. So Freud has this odd, disturbing jigsaw quality while Jung is more of an orb. You see this for instance when Jung criticizes Freud’s libido theory because it “ignores” that life involves death; Freud outsources death to the ego-instincts, reality principle, death drive. But when we desire do we really desire death? To me Jung makes too much sense, Freud is more interesting because more disciplined. And both suffer equally from the fault of egotism.
A
Anon11/03/26, 17:24No.25631452
>there are people who still take Freud and Jung seriously

A
Anon11/03/26, 19:20No.25631749
Where is the god lacan in all of this I often think that if lacan was as popular for pop pseuds as jung and freud /adv/ wouldn't be a board and incels can finally chill the fuck out
A
Anon11/03/26, 19:29No.25631770
Jay Dyer is the greatest philosopher of our time.

A
Anon11/03/26, 20:34No.25631937
>btfo by Glaucon who is only playing devil's advocate
>have to come up with an overly convoluted and at best, supremely naive hypothetical to justify justice (haha) being an intrinsically good thing.
Really enjoying the Republic so far.

A
Anon11/04/26, 00:50No.25632369
I might do a thread Commentary on the Politics, but I'll effortpost on the First Book instead. Keep in mind this is not rigorous, blah blah blah and i'm pretty tired so i might not continue.Aristotle means to narrow his study to the city, but he must first define it as a “community,” and from that starting point he argues, in essence, that a city is a community, that every community aims at some good, and that the community holding the most power aims at the goods that govern all the rest. This community is therefore called the city, which makes the city the most authoritative of all communities in its control over goods.That the most powerful community can influence the smaller communities within it is obvious, but how it comes to control them, and how it earns the name of the city when we usually attribute that degree of influence to the State, is far less clear, and the State is not what Aristotle has in mind when he speaks of the city. We also believe that, unless we charitably assume Aristotle is speaking in general terms, the State’s control should not be all-encompassing as Aristotle envisions it for the city, which he holds must be of a particular limited size if it is to serve as a viable means of pursuing a good life.Aristotle begins his definition of the polis with the smallest community possible, a man and woman joined as a couple and a master joined to a slave. His first claim, that the union of female and male is natural and extends to plants and animals as well, seems obvious enough, but what interests me is that he regards the relationship between slave and master as natural in the opposite way, since he treats one as born to rule and the other as born to be ruled. He would then define what would be called the "natural slave" theory, which is that some men or women are by nature born to be the brunt of thought to those capable of independent thought, as they are, by nature, incapable of it.This has unfortunately been misconstrued in recent times as an argument for slavery, which is retarded since the Greeks were not racially selective with whom they enslaved; the modern equivalent of calling someone a natural slave would be "sheep" or "cattle" in the capitalist sense of the word.

A
Anon11/04/26, 12:49No.25633148
What is metaphysics?It means quite different things in different authors. But for Aristotle metaphysics is the science of being *as such* - what is being? This is supposed to be the most fundamental question, deeper than any other possible question. But on the face of it it is rather retarded - “is” is… “is”. It is too basic to be answered; being is presupposed in any answer to the question! Well, you’re right, this is one of Aristotle’s first points, “being” is everywhere, but crucially “being” is equivocal. The being of “x is red” is not the being of “I am” or “the bees live” - this is the first lesson. The fundamental being is life; living things “are” in the highest sense and the other “being’s” stand in relation to life. So what IS this being, οὐσία or ‘substance’? First, not necessarily alive - this is a simplifying shitpost, no substitute for studying the primaries. Still life has priority, it is most fully οὐσία. To be a living thing is to be some species - man, deer, rose. But the species is so general it misses individuality. How are these two ‘poles’ of οὐσία related? I would say this is the main concern of Aristotle’s metaphysics. He rejects the Platonic view that the individual is a mere shadow of the species concept. And because we’re talking about being *as such* metaphysics turns into theology in book 12, and books 13-14 are a refutation of academic theologies, which rely on quasi-mythological, pseudoscientific arithmology. Aristotle’s God is no One-itself, ‘he’ is Alive, and life is more than a concept, and in a nutshell that’s what metaphysics is, for Aristotle, imo thoughbeit.

A
Anon11/04/26, 12:58No.25633159
>he has to do metaphysics because actual physics is too hard for him to understand
A
Anon11/04/26, 19:22No.25633672
> Inasmuch as the reality of the concept of freedom is proved by an apodeictic law of practical reason, it is the keystone of the whole system of pure reason, even the speculative, and all other concepts (those of God and immortality) which, as being mere ideas, remain in it unsupported, now attach themselves to this concept, and by it obtain consistence and objective reality; that is to say, their possibility is proved by the fact that freedom actually exists, for this idea is revealed by the moral law. (C prac reason pref 3)
Normies always seem to forget this. With them it’s all about the first critique when freedom is in fact the corner-stone. Hegel and Schelling make the same error with their fixation on the Deduction and on the transcendental unity of apperception. They get seduced by this idea of a totalizing transcendental subject-objectivity ignoring how the entire system of theoretical reason implodes in on itself and is problematized by the moral law and freedom. Reason affirms this totality of nature but also transcends itself, affirms itself in ethics, so giving us the practical concept of freedom. Fichte understood this, Schelling and Hegel did not. And Schopenhauer COMPLETELY misses the boat.

A
Anon11/05/26, 02:17No.25634369
bump
A
Anon11/05/26, 03:49No.25634528
bump
A
Anon11/05/26, 04:52No.25634613
What are some lesser known thinkers in the vein of Ernst Cassirer, Karl Lowith and Hans Blumenberg?
A
Anon11/05/26, 06:25No.25634728
>walls of texts
This is why no one likes pseuds like you all.
A
Anon11/05/26, 11:13No.25634931
Besides that I’m rerererereading the second critique. Here is a very interesting passage that is essential to understanding idealism:
>The a priori thought of a possible universal legislation which is therefore merely problematical, is unconditionally commanded as a law without borrowing anything from experience or from any external will.
This is how reason *practically* transcends phenomena. It raises the mere possibility of the Law, of treating others as ends, and then this ought becomes a *practical* is. It raises this possibility because this is its *own* self-affirmation. But only practically - theoretically agnosticism must reign. What is the thing-in-itself? The “real thing” behind the “mere appearance”? In a way, yes, but to speak more precisely it is freedom and the law. This “ought”, this thing-in-itself, is so utterly transcendent that we never see it. We can never know for example that we actually follow the law, our motives are always compromised. But the ‘ought’ abides for all that. This is why I love Kant - his philosophy is about finding hope in a hopeless world. He makes the hopeless world ‘merely’ phenomenal without doing a warmed-over Platonism or Vedanta, which tends to justify this world. There’s a passage in cpr I wish I could find right now in which he calls for endless revolution, endless reform. This situation we are in fucking sucks but as the man in Monty Python said “I’m not dead yet!”

A
Anon11/05/26, 16:37No.25635278
I reread the whole thing this morning and I’m still perplexed. The death drive is a conservative drive that seeks repetition; it’s a “clap-back” to free cathexis, like a throbbing wound. But death is not conservative, living things in no wise “conserve” an original state by being inorganic matter. It is an extremely speculative work but it’s a nutty, unmoored sort of speculation that rests on a selective interpretation of biology. Instincts or drives are important in Fichte too but he would have lol’d at the notion of a death drive. Living things stand opposed to the inorganic, everything about us is striving against this.

A
Anon11/06/26, 00:01No.25636118
You're a metaphysician Harry!
A
Anon11/06/26, 12:02No.25636870
>As if indeed we could ever bring it about that witgout respect for the law, which implies fear… we of ourselves… could ever come into possession of holiness of will by the coincidence of our will with the pure moral law becoming as it were part of our nature….
This is another point of daylight between Kant and Fichte. Fichte is much more optimistic about our closeness to law, our capacity to know and enact law. No further thoughts for now though I gotta reread all of Fichte again in light of a rerereread of Kant. Then I shall be a wise man, a wizard.
A
Anon11/06/26, 15:21No.25637080
I seem to remember that Plato somewhere refers to Beauty as the appearance of the Good, but I can't find the exact source.Can anyone help me out here? Or maybe I am misremembering?
A
Anon11/06/26, 23:02No.25638007
Rereading the Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals today at work between job sites. A couple of thoughts:
1) Kant does in fact address man and market in this work. He says that mere goods that further life or its enjoyment have a value, ie a price, but a human being never has “value” but only DIGNITY. He simply did not realize how capitalism reduces human life to the commodity labor-power, partly because Germany was still practically feudal. Still what he says about markets is really quite radical.
2) The kingdom of ends is an anarchic ideal. It is no democracy, no monarchy (forget about the supreme lawgiver it’s a beard), rather autonomous men (and aleins lol) legislate for themselves and everyone else, every man a king. It was not a big leap for Fichte to go from Kant’s moral philosophy to full anarcho-communism. Some day we will be free. But first we have to free our minds by studying philosophy. Every day we act, our entire society is a sort of play where we take on a given role for 40 hours a week. Once everyone realizes it’s all just acting, that the powerful ones are just men acting a part, that’s when things might really change.

A
Anon11/07/26, 00:52No.25638200
https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/5682/pg5682-images.htmlThat’s the Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals. Under section 3 go to “of the interest attaching to the ideas of morality”, the last five paragraphs or so, there is contained the heart of the Kantian philosophy imo. “Why on earth should I see myself as free and under law to begin with?” Because you’re a rational being and reason transcends nature. Freedom, the kingdom of ends, autonomy, are simply reason’s transcendence. You are sitting there you read this post, in reading it you are beyond it - what does it mean to be “beyond”? Universal legislation independent of any empirical element, the subject who writes his own laws. To me this short section is one of the most profound things ever written, no more to be free “because of” something else (God, happiness, perfection etc) but to be free in and of yourself, and for this freedom to be law, duty, obligation.

A
Anon11/07/26, 12:28No.25639043
>[The systematicity of practical reason] justly suggest the expectation that we may perhaps SOME DAY be able to discern the unity of the whole faculty of reason and be able to derive all from one principle. - Second Critique, “Critical Examination of the Analytic
This completely belies what Kant says in his open letter contra Fichte that his system is perfect as is. All of German idealism is an attempt to rise to this challenge and derive everything from one peinciple - Reinhold’s “fact”; Fichte’s self-consciousness; Schelling’s indifference point; Hegel’s “amnesty” of the individual and the universal; in every case they are trying to get beyond Kant’s asymmetrical rather creaky critique to something that is intelligible through and through. But Fichte’s system points beyond itself (as does Kant’s), is in a sense an anti-system, while absolute idealism is totalitarian.

A
Anon11/07/26, 15:31No.25639266
I'm exhausted by background reading for Hegel. I read a little bit of Plato (The Republic and some other works), a lot of Aristotle (Physics, Nicomachean Ethics, On the Soul, Categories, etc.) and I'm in the process of reading his Metaphysics
I'm kind of exhausted by how much time getting an acceptable understanding of Aristotle has been taking me (about 4 months). I know that I should also read Descartes, Spinoza, Kant and Fichte, but I feel like Kant will be extremely boring to get through. I'm considering just reading his Prolegomena and a good book on his thought before moving on
A
Anon11/07/26, 22:10No.25639897
Bump
A
Anon11/07/26, 22:52No.25640003
I want to do a reddit longpost on Kant’s views on immortality and God since they are quite interesting; I’m going to write in imprecise but “plain” language so as to be accessible to those anons who are innocent of Kant.Normally we think of freedom as the freedom to do x or y, indifference and independence of mechanistic causation. But even this is not freedom because you did x *because* of z, your action is just as determined as if you were a machine. Kant’s conception of freedom is more radical. While affirming the ‘machine-like’ character of life, as he would put it as phenomenal life, our reason by nature transcends this mechanism. It is the nature of reason to step beyond what is given, and it is this ecstasis of reason that allows us to think ourselves free *in spite of* the mechanism of life. And this paradoxically free causality, being independent of nature, affirms itself universally; hence the independence of noumenal freedom is deeply ethical, it teaches that men are ends and never means. But we never “see” this freedom, all we ever “see” is our monkey-like, mechanized pursuit of desire. Still we can’t help but believe in freedom and duty which is its concomitant, reason drives us to this belief inexorably. It is a real necessity, we just can’t understand how it works.Now there are two poles, duty, which is as it were in an “intelligible” world beyond experience, and happiness, our motive in the world of sense. (Ofc these are not always and necessarily opposed). In order for freedom to be intelligible, duty and happiness must be connected, this is the only way to bring freedom into the world of sense, and this is something we *must* do as rational beings. But it is impossible - duty and happiness, freedom and sensibility are totally opposed to one another. Therefore this consonance of duty and happiness, the summum bonum, must, like freedom itself, be not actual (phenomenal) but as it were intelligible.Because freedom and sensibility really are opposed this consonance can’t be achieved in this life or indeed ever. Therefore belief in immortality follows from freedom so we can continue to approach this goal. Otherwise the summum bonum is dead and then freedom itself is unintelligible, but we must believe in freedom. The summum bonum as the intersection of duty and happiness involves everyone being happy according to his deserts, but this necessitates God as the one to bring this about. (The proof of God is weak ngl, Schelling thought it was basically a joke and Fichte completely ignores it).If one of the other idealistanons wants to correct me I’d appreciate it. Tl;dr - freedom, properly understood, is too big of an idea for death, because death would make a mockery of freedom by severing it from sensibility, by suddenly and absurdly cutting it short. The whole point of freedom is that we radically transcend the phenomenal world, so-called “normie” reality.

A
Anon11/08/26, 05:57No.25640833
bump
A
Anon11/08/26, 16:39No.25641640
>slop image
>slop general
what did OP mean by this, and how many cocks is he choking on right now?
A
Anon11/09/26, 05:03No.25642886
>tfw wake up after two hours of sleep feeling like you slept nine hours
A sure sign of impending psychosis. Watch out, kids, philosophy can cause psychosis. Imma go a splore a great big building reading the third critique then around 6 am have a great big breakfast sandwich and hopefully sleep tonight better.
A
Anon11/09/26, 21:35No.25644012
Reading the third critique throughout the day my goodness is the opening ever a fugue. And does the judgment really solve the unity problem? To me it just seems like another link in the chain, kicking the can down the road. His theory of aesthetics is brilliant but the “meta” aspects seem pretty contrived to me.

A
Anon11/10/26, 06:08No.25644953
I dislike ascribing a philosopher's views down to having a melancholic personality or historical circumstance or anything of the sort, but the more you learn about the German Enlightenment, the more you get the sense that Germany of this age was of a very particular cultural mood, and the heart of this mood was a strange unhappiness and a deep yearning that you don't quite see in England or in France. I've seen people ascribe this depression or sadness to the loss of the Thirty Years War, which completely destroyed the German population and permanently changed their future as a people, determining that they would be a backwards and provincial people forced to lie back and watch as the French had their century of glory. They say the German attitude came here from envy. And perhaps envy is also what motivated the Germans to embrace Weltpolitik and nationalist fervor, building up their navy to step on the toes of England, and getting 20 million dead. It could also explain the rise of the Third Reich and the 75 million dead. And it may explain too the Protestant Reformation, which may be nothing but a form of lashing out over being harnessed to the Papal yoke, a cry of rage from the humiliation.But I wonder. It's like the Germans live with a form of permanent depression somehow, they have some basic need within themselves that our society has absolutely no outlet for. And the history of German culture seems in large part to be a history of people who feel some strange and painful lack, some yearning for a life they cannot identify. Maybe it is some kind of Wotan style brutality, and maybe Hitler's Reich truly did give it to them. On the other hand, perhaps it was only the temporary belief that whatever they desire had arrived that filled them with life. Either way, this strange habit of theirs is so all-encompassing, that paradoxically they will rather align themselves with the most extreme and unabashed form of EU leftism - the total antithesis of their former culture - than to accept a lukewarm and moderate culture which is temperate in its beliefs, having learned from the past that this extremism is unprofitable.
A
Anon11/10/26, 13:29No.25645526
Rather than think of the power of judgment as a necessary “link“ to fill a gap between freedom and nature think of it as a need in the system itself - reflective judgment already touched on in the Ideas of Reason of the first critique. It is interesting that in Schelling and Hegel ‘reflection’ becomes a dirty word - because it’s indeterminate and begins from the given. Something similar happens with the word “formal” as something external. It is not the case that Kant “needs” this link to make sense of freedom, rather there really is such a link, the purposiveness of nature, purposeless purposiveness.
A
Anon11/10/26, 14:31No.25645610
Which bible's ideal for philosophy, theology, and metaphysics study? I'm getting nauseous researching this... Some version of Douay-Rheims? 1611 KJV? ASV 1901? I could get the Orthodox Study Bible (2008, hardcover) although apparently NKJV sucks, or the New Cambridge Paragraph Bible with Apocrypha (2011, hardcover). Not finding anything better that I could order online as a Euro. I could always grab a PDF online but a physical copy is always cool...

A
Anon11/10/26, 16:46No.25645838
>The consciousness of the causality of a representation for maintaining the subject in the same state is pleasure. - Third Critique
I have trouble understanding this. When we feel pleasure we are transported out of baseline. I should know, I’m a degenerate. It is similar to Freud’s conception of pleasure as the discharge of excitation and the return to a base level cathectic state. He is of course thinking about cumming. But it’s the brief moment of cumming that is pleasant, not the post-cum per se, so how can you define pleasure in terms of release? The baseline only enters accidentally.
A
Anon11/10/26, 17:08No.25645882
Is longtermism really worth researching?
A
Anon11/10/26, 20:05No.25646278
Man nigga fuck the third critique, I’ve read it twice before, I know the gist. Some of Kant’s finer claims are so questionable, like that composite colors cannot be beautiful, or that color in general is merely charming. And the big picture stuff is insightful but quite simple. I’m also frankly burned out on his uniquely tortuous prose style for now which seems to get worse as he got older. So fuck the Metaphysics of Morals, it’s a minor work. And fuck Religion Within the Bounds, I just can’t be fucked. I’m jumping ahead to a main course rereread of picrel. In this version of the Wissenschaftslehre Fichte leads the reader through a series of self-experiments that establish the intelligible world and our eternity among other things.

A
Anon11/10/26, 22:26No.25646609
Maybe it would be worthwhile to do short posts summarizing Fichte. He is such an esoteric philosopher it would be valuable for me to try to explain him in normie terms.Fichte’s goal in the Wissenschaftslehre is to construct the world synthetically from its deepest root, the I. This is very different from Kant who is basically analytic - he takes the given world and tries to make sense of it. And at least in the Nova Methodo lectures Fichte leads you through a series of self-experiments. Can you imagine a more literally autistic philosophy? But the proof is in the pudding as they say.For the first experiment look at the wall and then think of yourself. Notice how in thinking of yourself you are a subject-object, your self-consciousness is immediate, to put it in Fichtean terms you posit yourself as positing. But to be free means that all of reality can be understood in terms of the I. If the I is instead fundamentally relative to nature then you are no longer free. This is not to deny very real limits on ourselves including the limit OF our “selves”, our personalities. Still an I-first philosophy, a philosophy that understands reality in terms of consciousness rather than the reverse, is absolutely necessary if we are to know ourselves as free and create an anarcho-communist utopia. It should be obvious that this self-consciousness or “intellectual intuition” is prior to experience because it makes experience possible; it’s not a component of experience but an indispensable condition. It should also be clear that we are not speaking of a “soul” (we’re all Kantians here lads) but of an activity.Now pay attention to the wall again. Where’s your I? It is still “there” but as a thought or concept rather than as an intellectual intuition. Fichte calls this wall-directedness a “state of repose” and the I in this form a “product” as opposed to “activity”. For now just notice how these states are interrelated abd presuppose one another. This dichotomy will be essential moving forward. This is the first lecture, congratulations, you’ll be a wizard in no time.

A
Anon11/11/26, 03:54No.25647029
>/wall of text/ general
Ftfy.
A
Anon11/11/26, 04:46No.25647090
bump
A
Anon11/11/26, 16:20No.25647659
Metaphysics could be interesting, but it's generally used by religious retards as a vector for their dogshit apologetics. God is not real. Trying to argue he is "necessary" or some other such nonsense is an immediate indication that you have a low IQ. Essences, or "things in themselves" also do not exist. If your ontology is not relational, you have no idea what you're talking about. etc.
A
Anon11/12/26, 12:10No.25649415
Anstoß

A
Anon11/12/26, 14:04No.25649529
To orient a bit - we have been descending deeper into the conditions of the wall experiment and, in particular, the conditions of the state of repose and formation of the concept of a goal. We have reached a remote point with this primitive feeling in which subject and object are one and the I feels its own limitation. Now like a yo-yo we begin to ascend again by asking: how does the I form a concept of a goal from these feelings?The real activity is checked by feeling but the ideal activity is not checked and possesses a drive of its own to reflection. This drive causes the ideal activity to “project” the limitation of feeling outside of itself (the I itself is unitary and can’t be divided into parts), intuiting its own limitation as the not-I. And herein there is feeling as well as the ideal activity is itself limited by its object, hence the feeling that our intuitions are ours. But this is a deep intuition in which representation and object are not yet distinguished, rather the not-I is simply other. Just as we do not experience simple feeling except by abstraction, we do not experience this deep intuition as such but it must be further developed into waking outer intuition in which representation and object are distinguished and the representation is localized in space and time. This entire intuitive process is the productive imagination; all of nature is imagination.Besides the limitation of the not-I our striving or drives are also intuited as the oscillation before a manifold of possibilities - the Ideal. It is from the ideal that the concept of a goal will be formed. The Idea would a completed infinity such that no further positing of the ideal is necessary, God, and more on this later.“Four different elements are present: a feeling of limitation, a feeling of striving, an intuition of a determinate object, and an intuition of the ideal.”If you’ve been following along we are now a quarter or so through the lectures. You have attained the grade of Theoricus. In no time you will be an anarchist wizard like Fichte.

A
Anon11/12/26, 14:40No.25649582
It is interesting how Fichte reframes the task of philosophy in the introductory lecture (which I haven’t summarized). Previous philosophical questions were always “Is x real and how is it real?” For instance in Plato - “are intelligible universals real and how so?”; in Spinoza “is there a first principle and how so?” Kant makes a great leap by asking how are synthetic a priori propisitions possible at all; Fichte extracts the radical kernel of this question by asking about the first synthesis between representation and object - “how do we know that there even ARE objects corresponding to our representations? What does it mean to say this?” Not “why is there something rather than nothing” (which would be transcendent) but “why is something something rather than a mere image? How is the real world real?” Philosophers look for ‘first’ questions and for Fichte this is the absolutely first question, the task of metaphysics.
A
Anon11/12/26, 14:55No.25649596
>The overall goal of human education and cultivation is to employ labor to make man what he previously was without the need of any labor at all.
A very based endorsement of anarchism in the introductory lecture. The endgame is a return to the state of innocence. Relevant to this, from a 1795 letter to the tradlarp realist traitor Jacobi:
>My absolute I is obviously not the individual, though this is how offended courtiers and irate philosophers have interpreted me, in order that they may falsely attribute to me the disgraceful theory of practical egoism.... As soon as we regard ourselves as individuals, we find ourselves at the practical standpoint. From this standpoint, the pure I is posited outside ourselves and is called God. How else could we have discovered God, if we had not discovered his attributes in ourselves after all? Realism rules within the domain of the practical standpoint. What is the purpose of the speculative standpoint if it does not serve life then? If mankind had never tasted this forbidden fruit, it could dispense with all philosophy. But mankind has an innate desire to catch a glimpse of that realm which transcends the individual, to view this realm directly. The first person who asked a question about the existence of God broke through the boundaries; he brought man into conflict with himself, which can only be resolved by proceeding to that supreme point where speculative and practical appear as one. Presumption led us to philosophize and this cost us our innocence. We caught sight of our nakedness and since then we have had to philosophize for our salvation.
A
Anon11/12/26, 18:19No.25649922
New to /phil/ in general with no formal education in it. I was looking for some good books to learn more about taoism but wasn't really sure where to start or go and a overall interest in eastern beliefs. Found "The way of Zen" but was unsure if something else would be better instead for a introduction.

A
Anon11/12/26, 18:32No.25649943
Hi all - I'm compiling a reading list to approach poststructuralism from a Marxist lens for analysis. Would anyone have a reading guide for approaching Foucault, Derrida, etc.? I've got some pointers on Lacan, Althusser, and Heidegger, but that's it.
A
Anon11/12/26, 20:22No.25650187
“I see absolutely no way of giving the Jews civil rights, except perhaps if one chops off all of their heads and replaces them with new ones, in which there would not be one single Jewish idea.” - Johann Fichte, 1793BASEDBASEDBASEDBASEDBASE
A
Anon11/13/26, 12:45No.25651382
I got filtered by Plato's Parmenides. What do? Should I read some actual Parmenides or something else first to understand what he means by "the one"?
A
Anon11/13/26, 21:49No.25652170
A lot of anons complain that German idealism is too autistic or hard to read but this is a simple alignment issue. All of the great idealists were heavy snuff users and to understand their works you need to get on their level. Kant regularly mentions his snuff habit in his diaries; Hegel got through an ounce a day; Fichte loved snuff so much that he would eat it instead of sniffing it. Snuff is nothing like other forms of tobacco - it’s very stimulating, frankly conparable to a less speedy cocaine buzz. Large amounts make your palms sweat. Most importantly it clears your mind; I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been stuck on a line of Latin poetry or philosophy and with a hit of snuff it all falls into place. So if yoy want to think like Kant, Fichte and Hegel you need snuff - and coffee. Their writing is wild because they were j-j-j-jacked up on snuff and black coffee.

A
Anon11/14/26, 00:09No.25652423
Do we really have to do this malfoid shit
A
Anon11/14/26, 00:19No.25652436
I hate the crab mentality here. You can’t say anything without incurring these pissant attacks. I do the same desu, it’s the culture. Reddit’s too curated but 4chan sucks balls as well. Once in a very blue moon you get an intelligent effortful usually rather offbeat response and that’s the pull.I keep bitching about picture thinking and fake philosophy. I just mean that “real” philosophy pushes the bounds of thinking and is hence hard to read. Aristotle, Spinoza, any medieval philosophy, any German idealism, Kierkegaard, Husserl, Deleuze are all examples of “real” philosophy. Fake philosophy is picture-thinking - most of Plato, Schoppie, Descartes, Neechee, James, gnostic wankery are all fake bullshit philosophers. Most anons only read the fake stuff and actively look down on “real” philosophy.
A
Anon11/14/26, 00:19No.25652437
bite me, retards

A
Anon11/14/26, 13:56No.25653514
One of the most confusing aspects of Fichte’s Nova Methodo lectures is the significance of intuition and concept. Fichte seems to say utterly contradictory things with these terms. Simply put, intuition/concept is a schema that can be applied up and down his metaphysics. Intuition is, as in Kant, the immediate, and the concept is the mediate. In the Grundlage Fichte is concerned with the infinitely postponed resolution of the finite and the infinite, in the Nova Methodo lectures it is the resolution of the mediated and the immediate - as if you threw a stone in a pond and the ripples went on forever and the Wissenschaftslehre was the physics of the ripples.As you awake from sleep sometimes you experience an object with no sense of self, a sheet other; that’s intuition, as you wake and regain your sense of self it is concept. As you are in the process of doing something you are intuiting your doing, but your goal is mediated, a concept. Having done something what you have done is intuited, your goal of what to do next is concept. When you think of yourself you intuit yourself, when you intuit the not-I your I is a concept, a thought. Something similar happens with the pair determinacy/determinability. Fichte writes in this “confusing” way because he thought fixed terminology led to dead thinking, even that this was what had led to the corruption of the Kantian philosophy.

A
Anon11/14/26, 17:31No.25653804
>An external object is an interpretation of our own feeling.
Even in the 18th century leftists were gay.
A
Anon11/14/26, 21:57No.25654364
The 10th lecture is about the a priori and idealistic character of space. But tbf I don’t think anyone is following now and if they were interested enough to follow all these they will probably be reading the primaries anyway. However I will give you a brief thought experiment: look around you, now consider that everything could be completely rearranged if you wanted/had the power to rearrange it. That’s the ideality of space. Things aren’t just “there”, the “there” is an opening for “could be there instead”. This is because space is not a brute given, space and matter only make sense to us in relation to freedom. This is something dogmatists will never understand.

A
Anon11/15/26, 03:17No.25654783
Today I woke up, read about 10-15 pages of philosophy, and then went on a morning walk. Immediately I got an idea, so I went back inside and grabbed my pocket-size journal and a pen and wrote the idea down. I then went back outside and started walking, my head was absolutely exploding with ideas, and I'd stop almost every 10 or 20 paces to write something down. Even once I got home, it just kept going, and I had to forcibly decide that I was done thinking and done writing down ideas, or it would have probably not stopped. And to be honest, I knew after writing down all these thoughts that they were impressive, really impressive. In terms of originality and skill of expression, they're equal to some of the best of our philosophers. This is, naturally, a very odd experience for me. I'm sure that everyone would just think, "Oh he's going through a manic episode", "Oh he's psychotic", and I honestly would almost prefer that to be the case. Because to think from a sober perspective that you genuinely are at that level is a very surreal and uneasy experience. Like if it's just me that's crazy, then that's almost preferable, because then it's just a matter of one guy being crazy. But if I really -am- that talented, then it's like the entire world has gone insane, because why should I be that talented?I'm not going to post any of it here, sorry. I just had to get this off my chest because it's so crazy. When you're like a 16 year old kid who has some vague inkling that he's very gifted in some way, it's very fun to daydream about, but when you become convinced that you truly simply are this way, and that the closest people to you are all dead men in books, it somehow stops being fun. It just becomes a terribly odd thing.
A
Anon11/15/26, 11:59No.25655359
Kant derives this elaborate transcendental economy with apperception, imagination, the noumenon, etc. and you can hardly avoid suspecting that it is BS. He is merely analyzing experience, this is Maimon’s main criticism. But Fichte manages to deduce all of these features a priori. Truly a remarkable accomplishment. Part of this is emphasizing what Kant himself says in the second and thirs critiques - the thing in itself is not a spooky “thing” but freedom. So for instance take a free will - it’s not conditioned, it’s extratemporal as in Kant. Yet in acting it is sensibilized as a series of feelings conditioning one another in a line intuited by the ideal activity. In this way time is the schema of intellectual intuition and the transcendental aesthetic is made synthetic and scientific. Again take space - it’s the schema of striving in outer intuition, not simply something that has to be ideal because it is intelligible. It’s like Fichte extracts the rational kernel from Kant, and that’s just his early Jena period.
A
Anon11/15/26, 20:31No.25656061
Next read: “Enlightenment Interrupted: The Lost Moment of German Idealism and the Reactionary Present” by American Fichte scholar ((Michael Steinberg))