A
Anonymous10/16/25, 16:56No.18078818Exodus didn’t happen
Look at the state of Egypt after God decimated them in Exodus; there is famine everywhere, a sizable chunk of the population is dead, the Pharaoh and his army was killed after the Red Sea returned to its normal course. Realistically this should have decimated Egypt and caused the complete collapse of Egyptian society. However, there is no evidence of any of that, there is no record even claiming that such desolation occurred (and this is a civilization that recorded everything btw). Exodus supposedly happened in the 15th century BC, but according to actual history Egypt was experiencing a golden age during that time, no desolation or anything like that.
There is no evidence of the Israelites wandering in the Sinai for 40 years. I’m not expecting tents or anything, but they would have had to feed people every day or at least every week, yet we can’t find any remains of animal bones or cooking sites. In fact, actual archeological evidence shows that the conquest of Canaan by Joshua never happened and the Israelites were originally Canaanites, Judaism itself has roots in Canaanite paganism.
37
Replies
A
Anon10/16/25, 17:17No.18078844
>believe God's word or believe the ramblings of some gooner on 4chinz
I'm going to with the Bible.
A
Anon10/16/25, 17:18No.18078849
>Egyptians were notorious for not recording defeats they dont record defeats at the hands of Greeks, who did record the battles.
https://jamesjordanwriting.medium.com/egyptians-were-notorious-for-not-recording-defeats-721311f20919
A
Anon10/16/25, 17:43No.18078881
this is what he literally meant
A
Anon10/16/25, 18:19No.18078951
>Baladi and Copts made the Rosetta stone
You're a lying Atheist. The descendants of Ancient Egyptians are still around, they are still keeping their culture and traditions alive even after many foreign invasions. In Alexandria they had debated the Jews and accepted the Exodus and the fact Hebrews built the pyramids in 2500BC. Even the Gayreeks who studied in Egypt acknowledged that fact and were blown away to the point they left their gay philosophy for the Semitic religions. Ask yourself why would the natives abandon their ancestral great civilization culture copied by everyone for their inferior nemesis jew neighbors unless they had amnesia, or they didn't know about their history and culture which is incorrect because they kept and are still keeping their culture in oral and writing form.
They native accepted the Jew Holiness and you're just an Atheist butt eater hater. Get over it.
A
Anon10/16/25, 19:17No.18079085
The answer you get depends on what Egyptian chronology you use. The highest and lowest chronologies for Egypt are about 25 years apart, anchored by the Battle of Megiddo in either 1457 BC or 1475 BC. As of now which date is correct is still under debate.If you go by the high chronology then there's a candidate for Amenhotep II being the Pharaoh of the Exodus.
>father Thutmose III rules for 54 years, fitting with Moses' exile for 40 years until the then pharaoh dies, and is the only pharaoh of the 18th dynasty to rule 40+ years
>Amenhotep II is not the first born son of Thutmose III so he doesn't die during the 10th plague (Thutmose III's son was Amenemhat, known from inscriptions at Karnak Temple)
>successor Thutmose IV is explicitly not Amenhotep II's firstborn son (Dream Stele) so Amenhotep's firstborn was dead before he himself died
>Amenhotep's mummy has skin lesions on its neck and face, which are possibly scars from a disease he suffered in life, such as the Exodus' plague of boils, picrel
>Amenhotep has only 2-3 Asiatic campaigns on record, all early in his 26 year reign, years 3, 7, & 9. Compared to Thutmose III's 17 campaigns this is a drastic decrease in regional enforcement, suggesting (at least a temporary) decline.
>Amenhotep sent a message to his Nubian viceroy Usersatet, telling him to be wary of his people's magicians when choosing court officials (The Stela of the Viceroy Usersatet). Usersatet was a military commander during the pharaoh's Asiatic campaigns, which experience Amenhotep calls upon as pretext to the further command he gives about weariness, implying the contexts are related.
>The city of Avaris, which preceded Pi-Ramesses and was home to a large proportion of Canaanite-descended people, was abandoned in the middle of the 18th dynasty, when Amenhotep II reigned
>Exodus and supporting biblical verses never explicitly state Pharaoh went down with his army, always described as his chariots, horses & riders, but never himself
A
Anon10/16/25, 23:17No.18079681
i also believe it didn't happen
A
Anon10/17/25, 04:48No.18080359
>Realistically this should have decimated Egypt and caused the complete collapse of Egyptian society.
Decimate? Yes. Complete collapse? Not so sure about that one.>there is no record even claiming that such desolation occurred
The Bible says it happened, and last I checked that counts as a record whether or not you agree with it.
>Exodus supposedly happened in the 15th century BC,
In my timeline I put it around 1530 BC or slightly earlier, so 16th century BC. I add 40 years because 1 Kings 6:1 says it was the 480th year since Israel "was come out of" Egypt, which is similar language used in Deuteronomy 4:46. The Deuteronomy passage clearly refers to the end of the forty years in the wilderness (rather than the beginning) as being when they "had come forth" out of Egypt. So my chronology is 40 years longer, pushing the Exodus back to c. 1530 BC, which happens to match much better with what Paul's characterization of approximately how many years there were judges in Acts 13:20 (i.e. "about four hundred and fifty") as well.
>I’m not expecting tents or anything, but they would have had to feed people every day or at least every week, yet we can’t find any remains of animal bones or cooking sites.
Argument from silence.
A
Anon10/17/25, 09:04No.18080700
If people thought Exodus and other books of the Old Testament described literal historical events for thousands of years then future archeologists may well end up wasting their entire lives searching for the location of Mount Doom so they can see where the real historical Frodo destroyed the One Ring
A
Anon10/17/25, 18:21No.18081764
I don't find the Idea of an exodus (the late date seems more probable to me, but there isn't so much evidence either way) to be incredible, but the idea that 2 million Israelites where enslaved seems utterly impossible for the time.
A
Anon10/18/25, 13:02No.18084146
> no evidence
Kek. You think the basedboy academics at the Smithsonian would admit it if they found Rameses II's chariot at the bottom of the Red Sea? The entire field is run by atheist cope-merchants who carbon-date everything with the assumption the Earth is 4 billion years old.> egypt recorded everything
They recorded their W's, not their L's. Of course they're not gonna inscribe "got BTFO by the God of some slaves" on a pyramid. Their entire history is propaganda.> no evidence in Sinai
Maybe because God literally provided magic food from heaven that doesn't leave remains, you absolute brainlet. Manna and quail. Read the Bible. "Canaanite roots" cope is just them finding some syncretism from AFTER the Israelites fell into idolatry a million times.